All Products

In-Store Pickup Only

135 products

Filter

Collections Collections

Baking Mixes

Breads

Brownies

Catering

Cupcakes

Donuts

Holiday Specials

Mini Cakes

Muffins

Pies

Yum Yum Jars

Bean Free Bean Free

BEAN FREE

Corn Free Corn Free

CORN FREE

Dye Free Dye Free

DYE FREE

Linzer Tarts (6)

$27.00

Funfetti Fiesta (4-pack for shipping)

$21.00

Mother's Day Cupcakes (6 Pack)

$34.50

A mix of 6 Festive Holiday Cookies in a variety of seasonal designs. If you have your eyes on a specific design, please let us know in the order notes.

Sold Out

Easter Cookies (6)

$34.99

Sold Out

Gingerbread Cookies (6)

$30.00

Oatmeal Raisin Cookies (6)

$18.00

Easter Cupcakes (6 Pack)

From $36.00

Lightly Decorated Sugar Cookies in fun shapes

Sugar Cookies (6)

$21.00

Bundt Cake

$38.50

Mookie Pies (6)

$39.00

Fan's Favorite! Our double vanilla cupcake gives you a burst of vanilla delight in your mouth, with a vanilla, brown sugar and cinnamon smooth frosting.

Double Vanilla Delight (4-pack for shipping)

$21.00

A Creamy Butternut Squash with a warm hint of ginger, perfect for cold evenings or a dinner time treat.

Butternut Squash Soup

$9.50

Strawberry Basil Bread

$18.00

Rockin' Red Velvet (4-pack for shipping)

$21.00

Mac and Cheese (6 Single Servings)

$36.00

Filled Chocolate Desserts (12)

$45.00

Bring home some fun with our DIY cookie kits. Each kit comes with one predecorated cookie and a variety of 5 blank cookies and decorations for you to design as you wish. Kits are available for pickup or shipping. Instructions included.

DIY Cookie Kits - Choose your Theme

$35.00

Vanilla Cake, with Chocolate Frosting filled with Vegan Creme ** This online item is: "Store Pickup Only" and cannot be shipped.

Boston Creme (4-pack for shipping)

$22.00

Order our Mango Habanero Cauliflower Wingz for dinner or your next event. 1 Half-tray of wings serves 6-8

Cauliflower Wingz (Half Tray)

$45.00

Moo's Choco Choc (4-pack for shipping)

$21.00

Vanilla Raspberry (4-pack for shipping)

$23.00

Winter Cookies (6)

$36.00

Roasted Tomato Soup

$8.00

Chocolate Mini Bundt Cake filled with Ganache, and topped w/ Chocolate Frosting, Chocolate Chips and Chocolate Syrup

Chocolate Sin (3)

$21.00

Sani-Bani Vanilla Strawberry (4-pack for shipping)

$21.00

Mocha Madness (4-pack for shipping)

$22.00

Pasta Salad (Half Tray)

$63.99

Order mango habanero cauliflower wingz for a delicious bite. Order in multiples to serve the family. This order is for pickup only in Denville.

Cauliflower Wingz (Single Serving)

$6.00

Hannukah Cookies (6)

$36.00

Order these Giant cookies for a fun way to celebrate.

Cookie Cake

From $23.99

Ooh La La Caramel (4-pack for shipping)

$22.00

Mac & Cheeze (Half Tray)

$75.00

A Moist Pink Velvet cupcake topped off with a creamy pink vanilla frosting

Pretty in Pink (4-pack for shipping)

$21.00

Mo' Apple Pie (4-pack for shipping)

$22.00

Funfetti Fiesta (6-pack for pickup)

$31.50

Ooh La La Caramel (6-pack for pickup)

$33.00